Project Smart ~ Exploring trends and developments in project management today

Calendar icon
Adobe PDF icon

Who is the Project Manager?

Assigning project management responsibility for success

~ By Mike Griffin

Businessman illustrating a project managers key role

A project manager's prime task is managing a project to success. The products of the project need to be picked up by the line organisation, and if this involves change in the organisation or ways of working, the changes must be made to 'stick'. By ensuring that the responsibilities for project management and business change are well assigned in a project there is an increased chance of success.

The Dilemma

In all projects assigning the correct project manager is crucial. The choice is often not simple. I have experienced this in the form of a dilemma: do we appoint someone who is an experienced project manager or someone who will champion the change? Very often the experienced project manager will come from a technical background, e.g. IT, and will not have authority to make changes in the organisation or processes. On the other hand the change champion will have credibility with the business unit, but often not have the project skills required. If you can always find all of this in one person, then good luck to you; you don't need the rest of this article!

When Is This a Problem?

There can be a problem in a project that is not part of a programme. Let's look at the differences between programmes and projects. I'll use MSP™ (Managing Successful Programmes of the OGC) to illustrate. MSP clearly differentiates between projects - that deliver outputs - and programmes - that deliver outcomes. The main difference is that a project that is not part of a programme delivers the output to the line organisation; the line management is subsequently responsible for achieving the benefits (outcomes). A programme, on the other hand, is also responsible for the benefits realisation of the projects within the programme.

I have noticed, in our organisation at least, that projects are expected to deliver the change in the organisation, so the outcome is not achieved if the project only delivers the output.

How Does It Go Wrong?

To ensure a good mix of business change and project management, for IT projects, we have in the past staffed projects with a project manager from the customer, a "business PM" or BPM, and an experienced project manager from IT, the "IT PM", reporting to them. This can work well, depending on the individuals and how well they cooperate and complement each other. But if the BPM doesn't have the required project management capabilities there can be a conflict of authority: the BPM is in charge - the "boss" - but the IT PM needs to tell them what to do and how to do it. Hoping that the BPM and IT PM will complement each other and work well together is not enough, we have seen this go bad a large number of times. Roles and responsibilities, especially for the project management tasks, is the foundation of a project and if that goes wrong it is very difficult to correct. So it's best to get it right at the start. Having more than one person in a project with a role of "project manager" is confusing. There should only be one. This can be resolved by only giving the overall project manager this role and the IT PM is called an "IT work stream lead" or "IT team lead". Some IT project managers have great difficulty accepting this; after all it says "Project Manager" on their business card, and they expect that to appear as their role in every project as well. Of course a project role and a job title are completely different things, but we have found that this "role inflation" has crept into the way people see project roles. My goal was to ensure that when a project was setup, it had a good foundation to be successful. Of course the project team members still need to work together well to be successful, but giving the team a good foundation allows them to focus on delivering together, instead of trying to work out who they should listen to. I started looking for a solution to this dilemma.

What Did I Find?

My analysis led me to the conclusion that we needed a capable and experienced project manager to be responsible for the project management, and someone with the right authority and "organisational credit" to be responsible for the change in the business. As the experienced project managers available for our IT projects are nearly always from IT they do not have the authority or credit in the customer's organisation. And the main customer contacts, the potential candidates for the BPM role, often don't have the project management capabilities. Looking at how MSP describes the programme structure, the key players are the SRO (Senior Responsible Owner), the Programme Manager and the BCM (Business Change Manager). The key here is that the BCM does not report to the Programme Manager or vice versa; and that the Programme Manager is responsible for the day-to-day management of the programme while the BCM is responsible for delivering change and benefits. Why couldn't this work in a project as well? With a team of project managers I worked through the roles and responsibilities in a typical project, with the aim of making this work. The project managers were motivated in this too, as they had experienced the problem first hand! The result was a proposed project structure as shown in figure 1:

Proposed Project Structure Diagram
Figure 1: Proposed Project Structure

To explain to the Steering Group, other stakeholders, the project manager and BCM how the responsibilities are split over the project manager and BCM, we have also developed a RACI matrix and a standard role description. These are then discussed by the project manager and BCM, and if necessary the sponsor, at the start of the project. They are then tailored for the specific project, but have proven to be an 80-90% fit at the start.

Does This Work?

We have now started a number of projects this way, and the project manager finds that it gives clarity on the main roles at the start of the project. Also, there is little chance that the BCM will try and run the project, normally they have their hands full with the business change anyway! So the BCM is happy to know that there is someone else responsible for the day-to-day running of the project. A number of projects that started with this structure have completed, and the feedback from the customers has been good. On review the project managers feel that this approach works well, and also gives enough room for tailoring to the needs of the individual project.

In Summary

This problem only occurs in projects that are not part of a programme, but in my team we have a large number of these. Having a project manager and a BCM, with clear responsibilities and the capabilities to match, greatly increases the chance of success in the project team. I am aware that this is probably not the only way to solve this dilemma, and would like to hear from people who have other ideas and experiences, even if they are contradictory to mine!

Comments (5)

Topic: Who is the Project Manager?
4/5 (2)
Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarEmpty Star
20th April 2017 8:00am
Dr. Nishikant Bohra (Johannesburg) says...
As client is paying the cost of the project, it entails them to change the scope of the project any time they wish to but same must be told to them at the beginning of the project more explicitly about the iron triangle. Same is required to be reinforced consistently in formal and informal communication consistently so that they understand the trade offs.
Full StarFull StarFull StarFull StarEmpty Star
9th February 2015 7:46pm
Galina says...
When you create your own product, for example a website, it's very important to have a person who is responsible for the product (what will be shown on the site, how will the site look, etc.) I think it's correct to call this person a Product Manager, not a BCM.
9th February 2015 8:16pm
Juan Carlos says...
Product Owner is called in Scrum methodology.
9th February 2015 10:18am
Eugene Mulholland (Dublin) says...
A very good solution to what I am sure could often turn out to be a particularly knotty problem. My comment precedes a question...does this solution add to the overall cost of a project?
7th June 2015 10:28am
Mike Griffin says...
This doesn't necessarily increase the cost of your project, but could depend on your organisation's rules for project accounting, i.e. who's costs are allocated to a project or not. The BCM is most often already part of the project team, and by making the roles & responsibilities more explicit you increase the chance of success.

Add a comment

(never displayed)

What is the sum of 1 + 2 + 3?
Notify me of new comments via email.
Remember my form inputs on this computer.

Project Risk: Is It All Bad?

Road warning sign - Risks Ahead

Risk Management is an essential part of any programme or project and can vastly contribute to successful delivery.

Rolling Wave Planning

Blue rolling wave

What is rolling wave planning and how does it affect the critical chain? This article by John Goodpasture provides a detailed explanation.

Better Risk Management With PRINCE2

Red flowchart showing risk element

PRINCE2 has always had a solid, but simple way of dealing with risk. With the latest version a number of excellent ideas and concepts have been introduced.

Project Cost Management

Pile of British one pound coins

How do we know what a project will cost? We really don't until the project is complete because we can't accurately predict the future. What we can do is create an estimate.

PROJECT SMART is the project management resource that helps managers at all levels improve their performance. We provide an important knowledge base for those involved in managing projects of all kinds. With weekly exclusive updates, we keep you in touch with the latest project management thinking.

WE ARE CONNECTED ~ Follow us on social media to get regular updates and opinion on what's happening in the world of project management.

Latest Comments

Allana commented on…
12 Tips for Being a Good Manager
- Tue 5 January 8:30pm

George Bockius commented on…
Better Coaching Using the GROW Model
- Thu 24 December 3:55pm

Al commented on…
Better Coaching Using the GROW Model
- Tue 22 December 10:07pm

Latest tweets

General Project Management • Query on PMP Numericals about 4 days ago

General Project Management • Problems With Project Planning about 4 days ago

General Project Management • IT project management phrases - 10 terms you need to know about 11 days ago